I don't think it is the same one. For one thing, IIRC, the pouch on the former auction had the fold over closure while this one is torn off. Finally, checking the end date of the auction and looking at the feedback archive of both there is no corresponding feedback between them.
For a straight razor shaver it is probably not worth the $ for one of these but if a guy had the collecting bug, shaver or not, and has a collection of ducks the lack of a reaper is a large hole in the collection. FWIW, I like my reaper way more than my wonderedge when it comes to shaving. :shrug: OTOH, I wouldn't want to pay the freight for that one.