I am getting ready to purchase a honing stone. I can get a Norton 4000/8000 or a genuine japanese water stone at 6000 grit.
Which should I go with?
Printable View
I am getting ready to purchase a honing stone. I can get a Norton 4000/8000 or a genuine japanese water stone at 6000 grit.
Which should I go with?
The 4/8 offers more than the 6 IMO. The 6 isn't a finisher and setting a bevel with one is a stretch. The 4k can set bevels and the 8k can finish. So my money would go for the 4/8.
I concur. The other reason for going with the mainstream known hones is if you run into a problem there will be more people with experience with your hone and your problem.
Definitely the 4/8. So much more versatile and able to do everything you will need to begin with. That or a 3/8 niniwa super stone
Norton 4/8K or Naniwa 3/8K combination stones. There is more information available on the Norton, but the Naniwa is just as good.
I too will recommend the Norton 4/8 or Naniwa 3/8, these are much more versatile than a JNat, although a JNat can be used with different naguras to cover a wider range.
They are also both synthetic, which makes them pretty consistent, and you can take a lot of advantage from other peoples experience with them, like in the JaNorton Thread as opposed to naturals, where every stone is different and needs to be learned well to take out the full potential.
I would also go with the 4/8k. It gives you much more versatility.
Thanks for the input everyone. I picked up the 4/8k today at lunch based upon everyone's feedback. $79.99 at a local tool shop. I think that's a pretty fair price too.
Congratulations to your purchase. It is a good stone that will serve you well. Now you have a lot to learn and much experience to gain.Quote:
Originally Posted by mjlthuston
Be sure to read anything here you can find in the wiki ("library") or forums on lapping the stone. Have fun!
As said previously check out the JaNorton thread and also look at Lynn Abrams and Gssixgun on youtube and you should be off to a good start
I'm trying to set up a meet with gssixguns. We talked briefly in January about getting together so he could mentor me some. I'm new to straight razors. gssixguns only lives a couple of hours from me.
If thats possible then its awesome and will definitely put you on the right path.
I just drove a little over 200 miles to meet with some razor making mentors this Saturday...it's well worth your trip I promise you.
Quote:
Originally Posted by mjlthuston
What do you guys think about setting the bevel with 3k Naniwa, finishing with 8k Naniwa, and ultra-fine finishing with 12k Naniwa? Has anyone tried this?