Thank you. That particular shave was with the Merkur 23c. I got this razor for $20 on amazon last year. I'm going to buy the 34c today. I'm not sure if this is it or not.
http://www.amazon.com/Merkur-Heavy-C...rds=merkur+34c
Thanks so much guys for all of the feedback, I've been reading everyone's suggestions and I've been taking notes to read over before my next shave. I am so glad to be apart of this community, and am so humbled with the responses :)
After I get this problem solved I can't wait to share it to someone struggling with something similar to me!