Originally Posted by
BHChieftain
I went the coticule route for my first hone-- I think the general concensus is that it does not provide the sharpest edge vs. other options (it *will* be sharp enough), but it does provide a really smooth, comfortable edge due to the shape of the garnets that get released when you hone. My opinion is there is a certain level of sharpness you *must* have, but beyond that, smoothness takes priority (of course, super sharp and super smooth should work just fine...)
So, what I like about the coticule:
-Natural stone (just a personal thing)
-Provides feedback whenn you hone (feels like "suction" when it's done)
-Can't overhone on it
-Smells good for some reason...
Downside is the coticule is a bit pricey, and there is variablity-- some are harder than others.
Happy honing
-Chief