That depends on what you define as good. If by good you mean a combination of craftsmanship, performance, and price, Thäter brushes can't be beat (certainly not by Shavemac or Plisson). Absolutely fabulous stuff.
Regards,
Robin
Printable View
That depends on what you define as good. If by good you mean a combination of craftsmanship, performance, and price, Thäter brushes can't be beat (certainly not by Shavemac or Plisson). Absolutely fabulous stuff.
Regards,
Robin
Yea I was waiting for someone to really start this tread going too.
Personally, I like the two band. I have a Rooney medium and a older Simpson Chubby 3 and a Plisson HMW size 14 and a Kent from the B&B buy and I'm waiting on a Thater Chubby (if it ever arrives). Though the Plisson is overall the best performer I don't think the performance increase is worth the very high price. The Rooney is overall, I think the best though as I understand they have trouble sourcing the stuff these days. There's nothing wrong with the Simpson its a fine brush too. The kent is plain silvertip and is scrubby only because its a small brush with very short loft.
Normal Silvertip I don't like because it is too floppy for me. Best badger is really the best price-performance choice. It has a little of everything however the choices in type and handles are limited.
That's an "old" Plisson, right? If you can, try a new one for comparison. You will be surprised, and I don't mean positively.
I couldn't choose a single brush, but I think my favorites are the three following brushes (not in order):
-Semogue LE 09 Boar brush: why? Great backbone, great lather, very dense, tips are firm and not velvety soft but are also not scritchy AT ALL (none of that annoying prickly feeling)
-Simpson "Ehsan", custom XL2 in 2 band: why? Great backbone, dense, soft tips that have zero prickliness. Lathers easily and doesn't hog lather as much as my Rooney 3/1 Finest or my Simpson PJ2 2 band.
-GoldenNib finest knots: why? Velvety soft tips when wet, but still great backbone. Really really nice knots.
For reference, I prefer soft tips (softer the better) with good backbone. Not killer amounts of backbone, but still a firm, small brush. Also for reference, I'm comparing these brushes to Semogue HD silvertip, Rooney 3/1 Finest, Rooney 1/1 Super, Plisson 2 band (size 16) and 3 band (size 12) HMW, Vulfix Pure (Conk's Full Volume brush), and Kent silvertip (B&B LE 08).
In a few days, I will try the Goldennib silvertip Grade A knot and post impressions of that hopefully.
One thing that has always been a necessity for me has been a badger that was firm so that I could use it for soaps and creams. Needless to say any Kent I have ever tried and my B&B brush that you could run over with a car hit the trash before the shave was completed as these proved to be very floppy, even paint brush floppy. I have a 28mm Shavemac and one from a group buy and these are both OK. I think I like bulb cut better than tulip cuts with regard to the brushes themselves. I have an older Simpson Chubby in a 28mm knot which was my favorite until I got the big Rooney finest. It still is one of my very favorite brushes and no knot that I have found is as densely packed. That said I truly enjoy my newer Simpson Polo 8 two band. Of the Plisson, and considering the cost, I actually like the European White better than the High Mountain White. Most recently I have tried the Thater that Robin recommended and this brush while have a very nice amount of firmness is the softest feeling brush against my face that I have tried to date. I ended up buying a second. These are great brushes.
Lynn
I facelather soap 99% of the time. I like a brush with backbone, and a scrubby, not scritchy (if that makes sense) feeling on my face. Tips not too soft.
Of those I have, #1 would be the Rooney 2/1 finest. A Somerset two-band Tulip 2 is a close second.
I'd like to try a bigger Rooney though, if and when they become available. And yes, I am intrigued by the Thater.
In my opinion the best shaving brush in the whole wide world is Rooney Finest in style 2.
I love my omega boar. It's simple and cheap but it works like a champ for soaps and face lathering.
IIRC, Chubby II, 24mm. Those Thater silvertips are FANTASTIC!! Heinrich L. Thäter - Rasierpinsel Kugel II "Chubby", Clear The Different Scent:
I don't know the BEST brush, since I've only used a VDH Boar brush, but I love it and am in no hurry to try anything else until I have money to burn.