I can't agree more. If I were to keep Basil locked up indoors he'd probably hang himself. I find he is much happier when he's been outdoors and worked hard for at least two hours each day. Fortunately a young couple moved in next door with a shepard mix pup (about 18 months now)that is learning much from Basil. But the way they grabass in the yard can look pretty scary to the uninitiated. Dogs are very tough critters. They play rough and they work hard. It has always been my belief that a tired dog is a happy dog. I also believe that dogs have a natural tendency toward security. If they are awake, they are "on watch". Dogs, regardless of breed, make regular patrols around their "turf". I can't imagine anyone who has ever spent any appreciable amount of time studying a dog finding fault with an owner who keeps his dog securely outdoors. As long as the animal has fresh water and some sort of shelter from the elements and shade from the sun, she is more likely to be happy and stimulated than if she is locked indoors for the same period of time.
One of my anecdotal stories from personal experience. A few years back I was living in a third floor walk-up with my last dog Fritz:
http://farm1.static.flickr.com/26/44...baf78f99_o.jpg
It would get very hot in the apartment some summer days so I would bring Fritz with me to work. I had a Ford F-250 which I would park in the shade and leave Fritz in the truck with both windows all the way down and the split rear window fully open. In the bed was a very large bowl full of cold water. It was cold because every hour or so I'd run out and throw ice cubes in it for him (I was in Engineering so I had the freedom to do this). Even though he could just leave if he wanted to, every time I'd go to the truck with ice, Fritz would be stretched out asleep on the bench seat. Then at lunch time he'd get a full hour of running around and socializing on the grassy area in front of the company. I am sure this beat the hell out of being locked alone in a sweltering apartment all day long. Well, a woman who worked in te manufacturing area saw me leave Fritz in the truck one day. With no investigation at all, she went to Human Resources and complained that I was "killing my dog". The HR manager was a "dog person" (his wife bred labrador retrievers) and he took her complaint very seriously. He immediately ran outside to investigate and found Fritz lying comfortably in the shade with the windows all open and a bowl of ice water. He went back to the woman and told her there was no problem at all. She wasn't satisfied so she called the police to report my cruelty to my dog. The police came and found the exact same thing. They went inside to let the HR manager know they had received the complaint and found no evidence of cruelty nor neglect. The HR manager called me to his office and let the cops tell me directly. They actually wanted to know why Fritz would stay in the truck for so long. I told them I guessed it was because he had no place else to go. Well, the woman wasn't convinced. She was certain I was locking poor Fritz in the truck, in the sun with the windows all closed. She began telling everyone she worked with that I was a "dog killer" and when she saw me in the work areas or the hallway, she'd start shouting at me. Luckily she was very pregnant at the time so she was put on Maternity Leave for a few months and the problem went away.
It's amazing how some people can presume erroneous knowledge with no evidence.