Originally Posted by
Joe Chandler
Pretty good information, so I'll just add a bit about stainless. I really don't recommend anything other than the CPM steels for razors. They have a finer grain structure than the "normally" produced stainless tool steels, which usually translates into easier honing, greater edge retention, and more flexibility, as well as better finishing characteristics. You get less carbide segregation and banding with the CPM steels, since each grain of the steel is, in theory, a perfect copy of the whole. Any of the ones you mentioned will make good razors, with the exception of S30V (This is just my opinion, based on my experience with that steel). S30V tends to be very brittle and chippy in thin sections like a razor's edge, and good luck getting other than a nice satin finish on it. It's good for knives, which have a much heavier edge by comparison, but I don't like it for razors. Definitely not a beginner's steel, or a steel for anyone without very good equipment, as it's very tough to work with. A dead soft bar of S30V will turn the teeth of a brand new hacksaw blade.
Frankly, good carbon steel bar stock is probably the way to go. It's much less expensive and much easier to grind. You don't need to forge it, as forging really doesn't improve the steel...it just changes the shape. Forging is a much more economical (if labor intensive and chancy if you're new and don't know what you're doing) method of blade shaping, as you waste less steel, but in the end, all blademaking comes down to stock removal. The only way forging really improves steel is if you're working it down from very large stock, such as 3-inch ball bearings, a la Ed Fowler. I just wanted to add this to correct this seemingly widespread misconception about the relative benefits of forging vs. stock removal. Some guys see "forged" and automatically assume it denotes superiority. The thing is, all flat bar steel is forged about as much as it needs to be when it's rolled out into plates at the mill. Forging allows a person to make pattern welded steel, and to use steel from different sources (such as vehicle leaf springs...usually 5160 steel, which makes a darn near indestructible knife if heat treated properly, with good but not great edge holding properties), but doesn't automatically denote a superior blade. I certainly admire those who forge their blades...I used to do it myself. But I realized that for what I wanted a knife to do, stainless was just as good, and as Josh so rightly put it, stainless isn't a good forging candidate. I like carbon steel a lot, as well, and use some, but it's not my primary steel. I wish wootz and pattern welded were, but since I don't make it, that's an expensive proposition.:D
In short, call a supplier like Admiral, Crucible, or any of the knifemaker supply houses and get you some 1095 and O1 bar stock. It's fairly economical, you know what you've got to work with, and if you accidentally get a blade right, you'll have a good razor at the end of the process, made out of good material.
Good luck,
Joe