Churley (Aka: Colleen) makes awesome soaps, as does Mama Bear, and both have soaps that are easy on sensitive skin.
Their Web sites are
Shaving, Bath and Body, Skincare, Home Fragrance, Brushes, Creams, Soaps
Home Page home made natural glycerin shaving soap, aftershave, bath soaps, colognes
Stick with the scents listed as having essential oils if you are sensitive, or just ask them to recommend something, they won't steer you wrong.
My advice would be to try a little of everything you can get your hands on.
Also, I'll make an offer to the ladies, (
Ladies only guys, I don't care what color your dress is :w) if you want to try my soap, PM me with your mailing info and I'll send out a free sample puck. (yes international too)
I currently only have one type of soap, and it was formulated for my own use... I use it probably twice a week, along with my favorites from Mama Bear and Colleen.
(this is a very limited time offer, I have to make it so, or risk giving away too much soap. So if you want a free sample, please PM me before the end of the day on 06/21/08, and I'll send out free samples. That includes you Colleen, and Mama Bear, if you want to try mine out and tell me what I'm doing wrong, I'm always open to suggestions :D)