The first time I bought electrical tape for my razors, I asked for electrical insulation tape, and they gave me a black one, no clue about the company or thickness. Six or seven years later, now, happens EXACTLY the same (same shop, same brand probably, and that's important, stick with one type if you can't reset a bevel). As well as all the years in between, without any problems at all with underhoning or overhoning. No need for overthinking, and if you want varying thicknesses, use two pieces, one over the other. Or three.
It's just tape, and steel is actually wear resistant, your grandchildren won't have the problem of ruining the etching because the razor has been honed a lot. Don't worry about it, get the one more readily available, and everything will be fine.
If on the other hand you can find any good tapes that are wear resistant themselves, that would be a fine choice for edge restoration and coarser grits for the future.