Originally Posted by
DaveW
Particle size in barber hones isn't that small, and if you lap them coarsely, groups of particles can act like larger particles.
Also, they're intended to be used to thin the bevel and generally not to create a fresh edge. If you use them to thin a bevel instead of creating an edge (and leave the current edge to the linen and leather), you'll be a lot happier with how they work.
Sometimes you can lap them finely and duplicate the factory finish, sometimes you can't recreate what they were originally (not necessarily swaty's, but all barber hones in general).
Generally better to buy barber hones where you don't have to do anything the surface at all (i.e., leave the damaged ones for someone else).