Originally Posted by
JeffR
<soapbox mode on>
Which tools people use to hone their razor seems to be more a matter of background, availability and personal preference. In my case, I learned from my father, who used Arkansas stones (he was from Arkansas), and finished with plain linen, so for me the choice is as much about staying in touch with how my grandfather and father did things as anything else.
An Arkansas stone won't damage a razor. If anything, since it's such a slow cutter, and burnishes as it cuts, it might be more difficult to damage a razor with it than modern abrasives. However, the modern stuff can be much more efficient and consistent in how they perform than natural materials.
I'd advise trying different things, and trust in your own observations and sensibilities.
Hope this is helpful,
Jeff