Originally Posted by
Rubicon
The shellac you already have on there will work, it just needs to be properly applied (or, in this case, re-activated) and allowed to cure fully. Easy steps, involving cheap denatured alcohol, are outlined above.
Btw- don't subject it to warm/hot water as this will soften it because the waxes in shellac have a low melting point.
Tung oil isn't "oil" per se, that's just what it's called. It dries/cures/polymerizes just like laquer/urushi/cashew/shellac/polyurethane- transparent, sealing, and durable (enough). I truly think in this application it'll outperform your other options and will even look the most like what the Japanese use.
If I were you I'd use the Tung because it's waterproof and the closest thing, in every category, that I am aware of to traditional Jnat sealers that's readily available here. I'd experiment first, on dense wood or a rock or a brick or whatever's handy. Follow the directions, see what it does, and decide how you like it.
I'll get around to experimenting with Tung Oil on Jnats one of these days. The one I have was sealed in Japan so it won't be anytime soon though.
I probably tossed out WAY too much info, which is confusing. I agree this is getting too complicated. Do your research, take your time, and my $.02 is not to use anything artificial. IME playing with new stuff is developing a new skill and interacting with the world around us so, most of all, enjoy!