Now assuming both edges have the bevel pointing down and the lower is the touched up edge.
I think the bevel face on the lower one looks polished about right, but there looks to be micro chipping along the edge that could cause harshness that or the bevel was not completely set to clean the edge up properly or a few sideways strokes are needed to straighten the teeth out?
Is the lower photo pre stropping or post?
I only use a loupe so might look different for me LOL
Just my view YMMV