You guys know my vote :td
Again, when a new person enters the group and feels that they won't get a good shave with a razor just because the HHT fails, we have created anguish for that person that doesn't need to be there. If it works for you as an idicator, Great.
A shave will usually tell you if not sharp enough, how close to being there or if over honed. I realize that you guys hone a lot of razors and may feel the need for these tests. That is good when they work for you. If I use any test, I like Glen's test that when a razor will shave arm hair off the 4K, it's ready to go to the 8K and polishing stages. Even with this test, I usually keep it to when I'm doing old ebay type razors that need a lot of work.
So if a razor won't pass a HHT, does that mean back to the hone until it does?? That could end up losing a lot of metal and time.
This is such a personal sport.......gotta love it :y
Lynn