Initial Shapton Impressions...
Well, I've spent the better part of two days now honing on the new Shaptons. I'm very impressed with the quality of edge they produce. Some thoughts and questions...
It seems like the Shaptons will give you enough feedback that you can tell when you're done with that grit just by the feel and sound... When you very first start using a stone, you get kind of an abrasive feedback in the feel as well as an abrasive sound. The water doesn't flow over the blade or suck it to the stone, either. As you progress, the feel becomes more smooth, the sound goes away, and the water flows evenly over the blade. At first, I thought this meant that the swarf was clogging the pores in the ceramic and that the stone needed to be rinsed/cleaned, but doing so made no difference; the feedback was still smooth after cleaning the stone. Am I correct on the above feedback=done with hone? It sure seems that way. The DMT's seemed to always have an abrasive feel and sound, regardless of how "done" the blade was on that grit.
I'm still having a hard time getting my X stroke down (yes, I did round the edges of the Shaptons off when I lapped them). So I've been using a heel-leading, straight down the stone stroke. Am I missing out on edge quality by doing it this way instead of an X stroke? I know that I'll eventually have to get the X stroke down pat for smilers, etc., but that's gonna have to wait for now. The blades I've been honing all have straight, no frown no smile, edges.
One last question... should the swarf "skid marks" ( for lack of a better term) be even across the entire width of the hone? It seems like I always had an area on each stone that had more concentrated skid marks than others, i.e., majority of the skid marks on the right side of the 1k stone, majority of the skid marks down the middle on the 4k stone, etc.. I did make sure the stones were lapped completely flat, too. I ask because the skid marks on my paddle strop are completely even on every diamond paste size, except the 1 micron, and that's because the leather isn't completely level on that side. So I'm wondering if uneven skid marks on the shaptons means I'm doing something wrong.
Well, enough of my rambling. :) I think I'll go see if I can find something else to sharpen...