FWIW, I have switched from witch hazel to an alum block after coming to the realization that the witch hazel was conducive to post shave whiteheads (zits if you will). Alum block leaves my face much tighter. This is followed by Booster's or Clubman depending on my mood. I will reach for the Nivea replenishing balm if I rush the shave and give myself razor burn (like yesterday). :(