Alcohol based aftershaves
All but one of my AS's are alcohol based and I don't have any trouble.
Might be overkill but, alum block, then Thayers with aloe, then an Alcohol based AS just about everyday.
My skin is sensitive but produces moderate oil, oddly enough I may have had 3 pimples my entire life. Red razor bumps on my neck is another story. Since I started using the routine above and a straight I haven't had much problems at all.
Re: Alcohol based aftershaves
I use a Dominican Bay Rum from TOBS followed by a rose water hydrating toner from AOS And the bay rum is amazing- Definitely wakes you up in the morning! Any dryness that I may get is automatically alleviated by the hydrating rose water. Just my 2 cents for what its worth!