To each his own, I guess.
Good luck with finding a good balm.
Printable View
I would recommend Prorasso After Shave Balm. Hardly any scent and very soothing.
For completely unscented, I would go with L'Oreal Hydra Sensitive 24 hr hydrating ASB. I think it's part of the Men Science or Men Expert range.
I highly recommend Lucido as an AS. It's a splash, not a balm, but it is one of the best products of its type that I've tried...
Proraso white is not unscented but the scent is so light that you barely notice it.
Another vote for Nivea Sensitive. Great stuff, great price :)
Check out Al's Shaving. He does a few production scents but will also do custom scents which I think would include unscented. His stuff is also natural.
By far the BEST aftershave balm I have used is Razorock Aftershave Wax, I highly recommend it, it is mainly natural and very lightly scented.
My favorite scentless ASB is without a doubt the Truefitt & Hill scentless.
Thick, moisturizing and soothing.
Good, good stuff!
I have used both the nivea and AOS after shave lotion. While I believe the nivea is a great product nothing makes my face feel as good as the AOS unscented. It is just a wonderful treat to end a shave.