Okay, I've had several shaves to test out my blend. Overall, I'm pleased with the results. Compared to Castle Forbes pre shave balm and Taylor of Old Bond Street's Herbal Pre-Shave Gel, my blend is functionally similar. All three "work". The only down side to my home made blend is the greasy feeling left on my hands after I apply the oil to my face. I don't get that with the store bought products, but a quick hand washing takes care of the oil on my hands. Once I start shaving, it's really hard to tell the difference. Given the cost differential, I suspect I'll stick with the home made stuff.