C.O. Bigelow Shaving Cream options

I just bought 2 large tubes of Proraso shaving creme made for C.O. Bigelow. Because Bath and Body Works had a buy 2, get 2 free special, I also bought the shaving foam in the aerosol can. It seems to be especially fine and thick lather from the aerosol, and actually, I'm not sure which I prefer with this brand - the tube creme or the aerosol. Keep in mind that when i first started shaving with straights, I was using barbisol or gillette gel aerosol shaving cream without problems. Have any of you who have tried both products of this brand found a personal preference?

I have not tried the aerosol but do have C.O. Bigelow in the tube and love it.