Not sure if this helps.....
St.Charles Shave makes a product called, Bay Rum with a Twist aftershave milk, and I personally like it. It's a good bay rum with lime scent. It compliments both my Bay Rum shave soap and my Lime EO shave soap.
This thread reminds me that I'm out of Bay Rum AS. I'm also a fan of Bay Rum ( my favorite is Royall).