Which one aftershave for the rest of your life?

Proraso Cream. If you haven't tried it, you must do so. Very soothing and a great moisturizer.

Aqua Velva Original Sport. Although I haven't tried many AS, I could do without the others.

I love my Crown aftershave from the crown shaving company

I'd hate to be stuck with one AS, think I would get sick of it after a while... LOL
Alt Innsbruck is my favorite, but if I were stuck with one single product, I'd swing towards Proraso liquid cream simply because it doesn't have a scent making it more difficult to get sick of.

Thanks everybody for all of the contributions to this thread.

As a result I have acquired some English Leather and it is fantastic. I pair it with the roll on deodorant. It has always been an annoyance to me that I could rarely match my deodorant scent with my AS... problem solved.

I also have some Pinaud Clubman Original in the post. I really enjoy the Bay Rum so I have high hopes for the OG.

Still my one pick remains... Speick. It is a go-to scent for me... classic, understated, fresh and soothing.

Keep them coming.