Printable View
If I were to look for a fragrance to combine with MWF, what would I seek? An aftershave and a cologne, perhaps.
I am enthused about using the full line of Tabac with my lovely Tabac soap, as well as the DR Harris Arlington and perhaps the T&H Trafalgar lineup, but MWF is a standalone product and I wonder what would work to complement the wonderful wool fat.
I also enjoy T&H Spanish Leather, if that helps.
Any suggestions for an ASB/AS/Cologne to combine with Mitchell's?
I use Ogallala sandelwood. My wife loves it.
Hello, jdto:
You have a fine lineup of products. The final rinse generally washes away any leftover scent from soaps and creams with soft fragrances. Mitchell's Wool Fat fragrance falls in that category. Your aftershave fragrance, therefore, will not be diluted. As for Truefitt & Hill's Spanish Leather aftershave, my dear friend, that was made for the gods — and for pilgrims such as yours truly. I plan to visit my Truefitt & Hill Spanish Leather aftershave once or twice a week into the next century.
Stay well.
Jack,
BIG +1 on what Obie said :tu...Anyhting goes with MWF. That's the beauty of this soap
I agree wth Obie. Once you rinse, and perhaps use Alum, or witch hazel, Just about any trace of soap you used is gone.
I really like MWF soap because it has such a mild scent. I too think you can use what ever you want to for an after shave product. That Spanish Leather sounds great.....seem to remember that my father used that when I was a wee bairn.
Yes, due to its mild scent MWF is very versatile for pairing up AS's and EdT's. You can use anything, but I particularly like the coupling of MWF and Musgo Real AS. Leaves my face feeling softer than any other combination :tu
I like to use either Aqua Velva or any bay rum.
I've been thinking about getting some Bay Rum. I have yet to have the pleasure of trying that particular scent.
My two favs are Dominica and Turtle Bay.
MWF followed by whatever you want! :hmmm:
Oscar.
Thanks for all of the great replies and suggestions, gentlemen. I am on the verge of committing to a full size bottle of T&H Spanish Leather, as it has been the favourite of my T&H sample pack thus far. That said, I am going to wait until I try the remaining few scents from them. I do think that this would be a nice complementary product to my MWF. I understand that the soap scent washes away by the time you get to the aftershave, but I also enjoy scents that compliment one another throughout the shave. For example, I would probably avoid using Proraso to shave and then applying spanish leather as an aftershave, preferring to continue the Proraso experience through to the end. Same goes with my Trafalgar shaving cream and ASB, which I found delightful. I would happily follow that with their cologne, which is also a potential keeper, though I do find it fades rather quickly.
All that said, MWF has a nice mild aroma, which really could blend in well with a variety of other shaving products, so I probably can't go wrong. It was the first "premium" full size soap I ordered, along with a backup puck. Since then I've also added the T&H soap and a few Tabac products are inbound. As you can see, I love my shaving products!
jdto,
I'm almost completely certain that you will love Spanish Leather, as should everyone IMHO :D. You can't go wrong with either T&H or Trumper's versions, highly recommended.
Visit some shops and splash on a sample...Quote:
Originally Posted by jdto
For me DR Harris, Tabac and MWF are exactly correct
and perfectly finished. I have some allergic reactions to
many fragrances and the light well balanced classic soaps
are all I need.
Of interest this is a personal, seasonal, event specific
topic. One should never wear cologne or perfume
to a wine tasting or a scotch/ whiskey tasting. But to
a football game (either type) to be followed by beer,
pub food and a cigar and friends... well that is another whole
pile of fries.
Thanks for the suggestions. I can say that I definitely enjoy the T&H, as I am working my way through a cologne sampler from them right now. I'll have to give the Trumper's a whirl at some point.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryan82
Easier said than done, my friend. I have been lucky to have Truefitt & Hill have not just one, but two locations within a 10-minute walk of my office. I will check the barber shop at the Royal York hotel, which is near my office, as I do see quite a few traditional shaving products in their display cases.Quote:
Originally Posted by niftyshaving
All three have been wonderful, so far. I think MWF has the edge, but Arlington and Tabac both make a strong case for themselves. I love the ability to rotate.Quote:
For me DR Harris, Tabac and MWF are exactly correct
and perfectly finished. I have some allergic reactions to
many fragrances and the light well balanced classic soaps
are all I need.
You are, of course, very correct in this assessment. Personal preference, time of year, type of event and many other factors come into play for selecting a scent. That said, I think I could almost get away with the T&H Spanish Leather as a regular go-to fragrance. It's still early days for me, though, so I'm not going to make the call just yet.Quote:
Of interest this is a personal, seasonal, event specific
topic. One should never wear cologne or perfume
to a wine tasting or a scotch/ whiskey tasting. But to
a football game (either type) to be followed by beer,
pub food and a cigar and friends... well that is another whole
pile of fries.
I recently have been combining in my mug a sample wedge each of SRD soap sandalwood & vanilla bourbon as well as a chunk roughly the same size of MWF this makes a great lather and the combined sent really stays around but is not over powering SWMBO loves it and my brother even commented on my new "aftershave" when I explained what it was his reply was "soap , really I gotta try some of that"Quote:
Originally Posted by jdto
I'd like to try some SRD soaps, but the shipping is prohibitive for me to just buy a soap from them. I'll likely include the soap when I make a larger order at some time in the future.
As for scents, the full lineup of Tabac was a bit strong for me. The soap is nice on its own, but the aftershave and balm are not for me. I am going to have to move them to someone who will enjoy them.
I like the castle forbes lime aftershave as well . The scent is strong but not over powering and it fades rather quickly. I have to give the shave cream another shot tho.Quote:
Originally Posted by jdto
IMHO you can use any cologne or aftershave with MWF. It's scent is not strong, so it won't clash with anything you splash on after your shave.Quote:
Originally Posted by jdto