Originally Posted by
rum
I would personally go for 1805 or the Castle Forbes. The former has a great scent, though maybe not really Old Spice-like. For me this is a fantastic fruity scent and would definitely choose it. The Castle Forbes is a great performer and it smells like a bag of nuts to me. Don't worry about the scent though as I found it didn't linger very much (well, except the Limes maybe - that was surprisingly strong!).
I would say +1 for Tabac Original after shave. It's a great scent and has the vibe that you are after.
I hope this helps!