Originally Posted by
Ben325e
I have a 7/8 Robeson that was a crappy shaver. It's in great condition, all original, but just gave a harsh shave. I would go through my honing regimen, and finished on a chinese 12k, and didn't like how it shaved, so I went and tried some chromium oxide. Vast improvement, but still not great.
Fast forward to trying a shapton 16k. In the week after I got the shapton, I shaved with the 7/8 Robeson three times! I originally didn't think that the 16k would be that good, but it was. 5-10 passes on CrO after the 16k, and so far everything has been a great shaver. Different razors like different hones. Some of my other razors shave like a dream right off of the chinese 12k.
Basically, don't judge your razor because of the hone. I think that pairing the right razor with the right hone is the key. So, here's the idea: Sell one of your pretty razors that you'd part with easily for 100 bucks. Buy a Shapton 16k, hone up all your other razors. If you don't like the 16k, then sell it here for 75 bucks. It'll go fast. If you do like it, then you've managed to keep 14 razors instead of 7 or so, and you've picked up a new hone. Its a win win situation.