Thanks for all the ideas guys!! I may be further from knowing what I want than I was before starting this thread, which isn't a bad thing!
ace, I've been shaving with a straight for maybe 2 months or so now. I have 2 razors, a Bengall I got from Zephyr on the classifieds here, and a Torrey that I got at an antique shop that I cleaned up and honed myself (turned out pretty good, just can't get the very tip of the toe as sharp as I'd like, it has a slight smile to it). So I'm getting better and better with every shave, and it looks like I'll be sticking with it.
I may wind up buying a couple $200 or so razors instead of one for $400-500. But who knows! I like seeing all your guys recommendations, they all look like great razors. Keep the ideas coming! And I definitely will post pics when I eventually decide on something.:p Thanks much all!