Tyler,
I love the straight razor. I love the double edge razor. Each provides its own distinct pleasure. Each also provides a superb shave. Because of arthritis in my hands, I use the double edge razor more frequently. Often I use it by itself. When using the straight, I can handle only one pass, two the most, in which case the DE is used as finisher. The DE has always given me just as good a shave as the straight. The DE is also a good travel companion and less demanding. Of course, it does not hold the romance of the straight.