Steve's a true gentleman to deal with. I have one of his custom made paddle strops and it's a thing of beauty. The craftsmanship is second to none.
Attachment 136691
I bought my first straight from him too so I knew what shave ready was really like.
ninjaplease, it could be the difference in grind too. There is a difference between a full hollow and 1/2 hollow. I have examples of both and it depends on the day which grind I prefer, that's the beauty of this pursuit.
If you're comfortable using a hone, a couple of light passes on a Naniwa 12k couldn't hurt. You could follow up with 5 or so laps on a CROX pasted paddle if you have one.