Howdy all,
I was wondering if it was possible to over strop a blade?
Or is stropping just good news all around no matter how much?
Printable View
Howdy all,
I was wondering if it was possible to over strop a blade?
Or is stropping just good news all around no matter how much?
good news.Quote:
Originally Posted by basil
i have never seen anyone over strop.
we are not talking about paste etc just clean lather stropping.
Yup just leather and canvas stropping
I think it would take a whole lot of stropping to get to that point. A lot of guys routinely strop 50 linen & 100 leather before a shave. Just a wild guess, but I doubt we'd see anything nerve-racking before 1000 laps. Of course I'm assuming that your technique is correct the whole time.
Anyone up for an experiment? :popcorn:
I always do 50/100 before a shave and 25/50 after one.
Well I just finished stroping a razor for an hour that had magically lost its edge. Figure I was doing 1 lap per 2 seconds on average - 15 minutes of testing and getting the feeling back in my forearm. Other than recovering the edge and making it hard to type I don't think anything ill has come of it.
_Will
I have to agree that (if done correctly) canvas/leather is a good thing and you can never have too much of a good thing :) IMO
basil,
With good stropping I would doubt if any harm is done at all.
With bad stropping, much harm could be done.
When I started, I took the edge off my first razor four (4) times by bad stropping :(
Have fun !
Best regards
Russ
Other than wasting your time, there is no problem with over stropping.
I've been blessed with good form right from the get go and my blades shave perfectly. I was only worried that because I love stropping and just being able to relax while doing it I might over do it some day.
The only danger with a ton of stropping is letting your technique go - as long as you have good stropping technique, you can do 1000 laps with no problem! (not sure why you would want to go past 100, though)
Good question and I'm glad to see the answer is no...I strop the HELL out of my blades! So much so, I'll probably get carpal tunnel someday! :)
Not that I've ever noticed.Quote:
Originally Posted by basil
I did an experiment once where I dulled a blade and then tried to strop it back to sharpness. It took roughly 1200 strokes over nearly an hour but it worked. Not sure why stropping blade that was already sharp would be bad, but I guess it's theoretically possible to oversharpen it similar to the risk one faces on a conventional hone, but I suspect it would take quite a bit of dedication and time to do it.