Good Evening Gentlemen!
Joe those are very nice choices for the #5 scent....especially the vanilla :hmmm:
You tested #5 because it had good potential for a base.....but the rose blend, the way it smells....was not up for a SRP label.
The Base of number one is attractive because it is simple, and a good all around AS. It could be rounded out though, I can add small amounts of shea, to help with moisturing the skin, and another of the ingredients to aide with how your skin feels thru out the day. Just some minor tweaks.
While most of you liked the scent of #1....the scent of #3 and #6 was preferred.
So I can take the base of number one, and scent it with_________?
The base of four and five are variants of each other, so I could understand what needed to be adjusted, killing two birds with one stone. The key here is to take the best properties of number four and number five and put them together.
So the hybrid base of #4/5 can be scented with_______?
and the base #4/5 can be scented with a new blend......everyone already knows what #3 and #6 smells like. This is your test....your aftershave, just tell me what you would like....and it will be done " to the best of my ability " ;)
Joe I like your idea....the rose can certainly be replaced with something else, I don't have any Tonka bean though. WoW!! lets try this....I'm going to tell you why I put those oils together and then you tell me what else want. For those of you who cook or like wine, beer or a good cigar....think of it exactly that way. The spices in cooking or the way that you can taste the different aromas/flavors of a good wine.
* Black pepper......dry, spicy, hot
* Coriander..........green like soft rosemary, but tart
* Vetiver is .........smooth, rich and smoky
* Geranium...........green like grass and smooth
Here is an example list of words......woody, green, citrus, oranges, sharp, crisp, lime, clean, fresh, spicy, smooth, sweet, tart, floral, sugar, vanilla, bourbon, tequila, leather, laundry hanging on the line, pine needles, fresh cut hay, old books, peaches, moss, and last but not least.....dirt....freshly turned garden soil.
Tell me from this list which smells appeal to you and lets just see what happens, post your word choices here.....and make up new words if you want to.
Soapmistress