I have great success with Tabac. The smell is a bit detergenty but the shave is second to none IMHO. I like Mitchell’s Wool Fat, though a lot of people have a hard time getting a good lather on it. If you have hard water it’s an uphill battle. MWF gives a great shave if you get that good lather. Scent is akin to Ivory soap. Or lamb’s armpits, depending on who is giving the opinion.