+1 to Stubear's recommendation for Mama Bear's glycerin soaps. I also recently tried some goats milk / shea butter / earth clays soaps from 1846HouseSoaps sold on Etsy that have proved great as well.
....old snap of the works :)
http://rap.midco.net/bald1/shaving_kit.jpg
Razors: 1965 PAL adjustable injector | 1966 Schick M1 adjustable injector | 1974 Schick/Int'l Silver "Paul Revere" injector
Blades: NOS Schick Platinum Plus | Personna Platinum Chrome
Brushes: 2002 Shavemac Thuja wood 23mm Silvertip | 2007 Rooney Faux Ivory 2/1 22mm Super | 1999 Shavecenter German 19mm Pure | 2010 Omega/Marvy Beechwood 24mm Boar
Creams: Taylors (avacado; rose) | Trumpers (coconut)
Soaps: Mama Bear (various) | 1846HouseSoaps | Surrey/VdH
Scuttle: Feats of Clay