My top 5 in order are:
Cella
AOS ocean kelp
L'occitane cade
Body Shop Macca root
Edwin Jagger limes and pomegranates
Printable View
My top 5 in order are:
Cella
AOS ocean kelp
L'occitane cade
Body Shop Macca root
Edwin Jagger limes and pomegranates
CF Lime
Proraso Blue
Speick
Esbjerg
TOBS Coconut
Not much of a cream user but here are mine.
1 - TBS Maca Root
2 - Palmolive
3 - Muskgo Real
4 - Nivea
5 - Kaloderma
Bob
Soap guy here, but I think Real Shaving Co. works a treat. Also enjoy Speik and T&H Ultimate.
MWF
Proraso Blue Tube
VDH Glycerin
Provance (the specific type escapes my mind at the moment)
Cella
and I have to throw in a sixth - Creamo for when I use a DE or a SE.
1. Acqua di Parma Colleczione Barbiere Crema da Barba
2. Castle Forbes Lavender
3. T&H Grafton
4. TOBS Mr. Taylor
5. Penhaligon's Blenheim Bouquet
Runner up: Floris No. 89
Ben
1. TOBS - Sandlewood
2. AOS - Lavender
3. T&H - Almond
4. T&H - Traffalgar
5. CF - Lavender (I'm sorry but I'm not impressed)
This is killer hard for me - because I layer, the aftershave is just as important to me as the cream itself!
Two that I'll always have in the stable are:
Acca Kappa 1869
Art of Shaving Sandalwood