I don't have an issue with threads like these - they tell me that seller X's idea of 'like new' may not be to our standards. I'm sure if he posts clear pictures with the pitting and the rust in the B/S/T and calls it 'like new' he will be called on it.
Of course Gary and Lynn have a lot of experience and I am sure knew exactly what they are getting, even though the description may not have matched it. I think the controversial reviews come from his descriptions not consistently matching the items.
Perhaps they do for certain type of razors (that Gary and Lynn are likely to buy) and they don't for other types (that newer less experienced shavers are likely to buy).
I think it's useful to know things like this. My interactions with Tommy have been positive so far. I haven't bought anything yet, but I did ask for additional pictures which he included promptly (which threw the item out of my price range and made him a good chunk of money he wouldn't have gotten with the original photos).
Anyways, I'd like to see a subsequent post if any attempts is made to correct things.