I Know These Aren't What They Appear To Be...

Printable View

10-25-2012, 02:32 PM
Prahston

I Know These Aren't What They Appear To Be...

... But, what about the case?! Looks nice enough to justify the cost right there. ??

Collectible Straight Razor Pocket Knife Black Case | eBay
10-25-2012, 02:40 PM
ReardenSteel

The case does justify the current price...if no one bids against you.
10-25-2012, 04:01 PM
sheffieldlover

of course most won't buy one of those chinese specials. But it lists 440 steel. And because I don't forge my own razors, my question is: is 440 steel hard enough to take an edge on a razor?
10-25-2012, 04:18 PM
ScottGoodman

You may also be able to use the scales off of it. I've never seen one of the veteran razor makers use this steel, so take that with some thought...
10-25-2012, 04:27 PM
unit

I will suggest that the case might be far flimsier than you might think.

It could be nice though...not sure.
10-25-2012, 04:33 PM
Prahston

I saw one of these or one very similar in an Antique Shop here locally but they wanted $25 each... Essentially it is a knife that just has the look of a razor. They are much bigger than a standard razor. But, I'll have to take one of my razors in and compare the scales. Might be able to canabililze for parts but the scales were probably 3x thicker than standard razor scales IIRC.

I didn't pay much attention to that case other than to notice it was nicely padded and some sort of vinyl.

This Ad and another I've been watching are just Buy It Now so the price won't change.

Just wondering what everyone though of about the case... I'd seen some various cases but all closer to $20-$25.
10-25-2012, 04:40 PM
Eekspa

Quote:

Originally Posted by Prahston

... But, what about the case?! Looks nice enough to justify the cost right there. ??

Collectible Straight Razor Pocket Knife Black Case | eBay

If you just want the case, this one is cheaper . .

Wholesale - Maxam Straight Razor Folding Knife with Marble Resin Handle and Storage Case SKRAZP
10-25-2012, 04:40 PM
unit

Quote:

Originally Posted by Prahston

I saw one of these or one very similar in an Antique Shop here locally but they wanted $25 each... Essentially it is a knife that just has the look of a razor. They are much bigger than a standard razor. But, I'll have to take one of my razors in and compare the scales. Might be able to canabililze for parts but the scales were probably 3x thicker than standard razor scales IIRC.

I didn't pay much attention to that case other than to notice it was nicely padded and some sort of vinyl.

This Ad and another I've been watching are just Buy It Now so the price won't change.

Just wondering what everyone though of about the case... I'd seen some various cases but all closer to $20-$25.

I attempted to send a message to you but am unsure if it went or not...could you let me know if you receive it?
10-25-2012, 07:25 PM
nun2sharp

14$ just for the case?
10-25-2012, 08:27 PM
DaveW

Quote:

Originally Posted by sheffieldlover

of course most won't buy one of those chinese specials. But it lists 440 steel. And because I don't forge my own razors, my question is: is 440 steel hard enough to take an edge on a razor?

It may or may not be, but isn't 440 steel what friodur razors are ultimately made of? They get a cryogenic treatment, though, which makes a significant difference on steel with a lot of carbides.

You'd have to know for sure what the carbon content of the 440 was, looking at an alloy chart and max attainable hardness, there are definitely 440s that are capable of razor use (google tells me that 440C is what is in friodurs).
10-25-2012, 09:08 PM
sheffieldlover

I know too little about metal apparently. I had an "AHA!" moment about casting my own 8/8 W&B's and buying a house in Malibu, but my dreams shattered when I looked up how to cast metal... I be too dum to b lurnin' too much things y'all, hurts ma brains...
10-26-2012, 02:00 AM
Suile

I perty sure these are just perty looking ulitiy knives.
bevel looks way to step.
I guess you could pay someone a dollar if ya wanted the scales.
10-26-2012, 02:04 AM
mainaman

Quote:

Originally Posted by sheffieldlover

of course most won't buy one of those chinese specials. But it lists 440 steel. And because I don't forge my own razors, my question is: is 440 steel hard enough to take an edge on a razor?

Henckels Fridour are made from 440 Stainless, so yes it is good steel the question is if it was heat treated correctly.
10-26-2012, 02:04 AM
Prahston

@ Unit ... Definitely got the message and have replied! :D

Yeah, I thought $14 for a case wasn't that bad. I haven't spent a ton of time looking but have seen a bunch in the $20-$25 range and so when I saw that it looked like a better deal. I like that cheaper link a lot better for sure though.

That Antique Shop I went to was some Multi-Vendor Mall thing where there were Antiques right next to brand new stuff. I held and looked at one of these brand new trying to explain to the person working there that they were not razors and showing her some of the differences. I'll try to get back there this weekend and take some pics of a normal Str8 next to one. It is kind of a neat deal as a knife but is just a standard slipjoint folder in the shape of a razor but quite large and thick. The frame made up a lot of that so I'm definitely going to see how close in size the scales are as if you could harvest the scales for another razor and the case for whatever then you'd be cooking with gas!

I have no idea about the steel or it's capabilities... I have been honing knives for many years to shaving sharp but I wouldn't want to do my entire face with one. I can readily shave hair off the back of my hand or arm with them but I think it would pull nastily during a face shave.