So I've been straight razor shaving for about a year (but I only shave about once a week, and I haven't used my straight razor for several months, so I am still very much a beginner). I bought 2 razors off the classifieds here, both were shave ready.

The first razor that I started out on I could never get a good shave with, but I kept working with it for a few weeks. Each time I used it my skin was very irritated. I switched over to the second razor, and I started getting really close comfortable shaves. And each time I shaved I seemed to be getting better. Well, I was so satisfied with this razor and the straight razor experience that I went all in and bought hones (norton 220/1000, 4K/8K, 12K, and a flattening stones).

I've watched all the honing videos and read all the posts. I honed the first razor about 6 months ago, and at the time I had been using my second razor for a few months, so I figured I'd give it a good hone too! Well, now neither razor will shave. I have tried honing them about 4-5 times each. I've tried all the progressions. I tried a session where I did hundreds of strokes at each grit (took several hours). Both of my razors seem sharp enough, but they will not shave for crap. Each stroke brings tears to my eyes. I can't do a hanging hair test--it seems that even when I was shaving well with my sharp razor that I couldn't do this test successfully.

I was getting a great shave and having fun before I ruined my edge, and now I can't get it back. Straight razor shaving is not worth it if I can't maintain my edges. I am not excited to keep honing as I don't seem to be getting any better anyway. I have been shaving with my electric razor for several long months now. I swear I have watched every video on honing, but I just must be doing something wrong. I don't know anyone who could teach me and I don't know where to go from here except to give it up.

Does anyone have any suggestions? I have thought about buying a new razor (maybe mine are hard to hone), or just honing more (but that doesn't seem to be working). Another huge problem is that I don't know what a shave-ready edge feels like, and I've tried all the tests.

Thanks for listening to my rant. I hope someone out there can save straight razor shaving for me.