Originally Posted by
Gehring9006
Welcome!
I switched to a SR about 8 months ago and as JTmke has said...I'll never buy another plastic razor! If you want to ease into it go ahead and buy your soap and brush first and use your cartridge razor. I wouldn't bother with a pre-shave anything while using a cartridge razor (to me - it just seems to clog it up). If you look around a lot of on-line vendors (Maggard Razors/SRP) offer sample size pre-shaves/soaps/creams/after shaves for not a lot of money so you can try a bunch. That way if you don't like it you don't have a lot invested in something you wont use.
You didn't mention a strop in your list and there are many options. I purchased a package deal from Superior Shave that included everything (except software (soap)) and I was very satisfied. The strop that was supplied was a hanging strop that worked and was perfect for a beginner like me; however I recently purchased a modular paddle strop from SRD and I would highly recommend that strop to any beginner. Its a little more expensive but I believe you will learn how to properly strop much quicker, you will be able to maintain your razors sharp edge better and when (not if) you mess up, you can just get another pad for not a lot of money.
Since I started using a SR I have accumulated a number of new and vintage razors. For a first razor I would go with a new one (no worries about razor condition). All my razors are good and do the job, but a couple are just a little better than the others. For new razors I feel my Thiers-issard (TI) Bison (from SRD) gives me the closest and most comfortable shave. There are other TIs that fall into your price range that would work just as well (but is not as fancy!).
Regardless of the razor you buy take your time and do your research, watch videos, search this forum for answers to your questions and remember to stretch your skin so you are shaving the flattest surface possible, pay attention to the angle and pressure of the blade and know where the toe of your razor is at all times. The best tip that helped me through my learning curve when I started was to use the blade of the razor to remove the lather. This will keep your pressure light and your shave comfortable.
Have Fun!!