I'm keeping it. I stropped it first, and was trying to follow instructions, but it was my first strop ever, and it still shaved me pretty good the first 3 times.
Yours still feels noticeably sharper than I think that one, might have been. I was super gentle with the stropping.
Either way it's just so much cooler. The little click lock thingy scared me I thought the blade was hitting the inside. LOL