I'll chime in on this. I started with a paddle strop. Unpasted. It's still unpasted. And I still use it from time to time. I like it because it slows me down! I don't strop at the speed of light whether I use the paddle or a hanging strop, but the paddle requires more focus, and it gave me a complete understanding of the X pattern. I've discussed adding paste to my paddle strop, but have decided to order a pasted paddle strop from Tony for three reasons. First, I don't want to loose the ability to use the paddle without doing "touch up" (yes, I know I don't have to paste all 4 sides), second, I want to see the proper application of the pastes, and third, it gives me a travel strop or a strop I could loan to someone who wants to try using a straight razor.

Two things about Tony. I also purchased a "second" strop from him and couldn't be happier. He mentions his prices are in line with Dovo and Jemico. I disagree. His prices are much lower because with Tony, you get a hand made first quality item. It's like cheesecake. You can get one made from a mix, or one that is made from scratch and baked. I'll pay more for the baked anyday. We are fortunate that with Tony we don't have to do that. Also, when I first discussed with him about buying a pasted paddle, he told me that "to be honest, just add the paste yourself". A stand up guy!

RT