Go for the bow ties, man. I often wear one, and BKratchmer is dead-on: you WILL look dapper and well-dressed. Jos. A. Bank has nice conservative bow ties for about $50--but they often have sales, too, so you can get them for a good bit less. And let's not forget that traditionally, it's been a bow tie with a tux (black) or tails (white). The recent fad of wearing a long tie with a tux is just vulgar.
If you want to try different styles of bow ties--I mean the size and shape of the bow--take a look here: Mainebows.com
I ordered a black bowtie for my tux in the Classic with points--very nice.