I have two coticules and I am thinking of selling one but don't want to make a mistake if I have something nice. I know that is an awkward way to phrase that but I don't know what I have and I don't know which is "better" (a subjective term at best)

This one is smaller and has a freckled appearance with a definite sheen as if it were partly burnished.




This one is bigger and irregular but it is wide enough full length of the blade- very comfortable to hand hone. It does not have a sheen and is more "swirly" than freckled.




Anyone have any thoughts on this or are they just two unremarkable stones? Trying to learn.