I currently have a Swaty 2-line and a pasted balsa for touch ups. While the balsa does an ok job, it seems the Swaty is only letting me practice my honing strokes without any perceived improvement to the edge. The balsa does an ok job, but just ok.

I've been reading about the BBW. I believe one could be had for ~$30 for a barbers hone size (2" x 4"). Would that serve as a good alternative? I'm thinking the ability to slurry would give me a wider range of honing capability.

Experiences? Comments?