Torreys are hard compared to old Sheffields, in general, and sometimes take a good bit to get right.
Go all the way back to the 1k as one disappoints. The bevel may not have been there yet.
As was advised, freshly lapped hones cut better, some slurry on the 1k to start is not a bad idea, either.
Once right, they are great and hold an edge well, FME.
Keep trying!