Passing Technique vs. Excellent
I suspect you're right about the "too polished" thing, threeput. I sent one of my early ebay razors along the 8k about 30 times and it didn't perform so well, but just a few light passes after a few light passes on the 4k ala the pyramid and it starts working. It's the technique really isn't it. Once you've got the touch you might be able to get by like your barber friend does and that'll do it. For us who haven't the 60 years experience we need the best tools to overcome our greenness.
Not to dis the old barber, but although his technique might work for the shave, it might not be BEST for the long life of the razor. I gotta wonder about some of the butchered honing jobs I see on ebay.
X