Printable View
Ok started researching scuttles.. Most of you praise both of the scuttles mentioned above .. With pros and cons.. I was dead set on the dirty bird until I saw the Price difference and some reviews.. I'm not looking to bash either one but what's ur pros and cons with both and your personal experience..
I had a RB scuttle and it did its job at keeping lather warm. I've had no experience with a DB scuttle, so I couldn't tell you about that particular one.
There was a thread on here about the Roberts Feats of Clay scuttles. Like the one I have but no experience with the DB one.
Bob
I've got one of each and haven't been able to decide which I like better. Either would be a real winner. Go with whichever speaks to you.
What size scuttle did you get from Roberts? He makes so many sizes that it's hard for a beginner like me to choose.Quote:
Originally Posted by maddafinga
Check out Schwarzweisskeramik. I'm saving up for the big one, lol.
What about George town Pottery, I have the G5 scuttle and I think since my purchase they've made a G20? (bigger). I like mine, holds the heat well enough, a good looking functional piece.
i have a dirty bird 1.5 and it is awesome, i have seen and read about the others and it has been nothing but good so i think it comes down to which ever one jumps out to you and says "BUY ME"
I have DB I got from a member here and it works fantastically well. Hey Sinnfein glad to see another SRP member close by.
I just received my Georgetown Pottery G20 scuttle in Hamada and colbalt blue. The glazing is a true work of art and it is big. G20 got its name because it holds 20 ounces of water. I have yet to shave but filled it up and put the pewter stopper in. It stayed hot for hours. I can't wait to shave. It costs more but really is beautiful.
I also have the GP G20 in hamada and love it! It stays hot for way longer than necessary.
It's nice to see Georgetown Pottery made a scuttle that holds enough water for it to stay hot long enough to shave. I have an older model that did not stay hot. I tested them with a digital thermometer used in AC testing. The vendor did offer to take it back which was nice. I have, or have tried pretty much every popular one out there.
They will all do the trick for mixing lather, Staying hot is the key. I FWIW did not like Robert's feets of clay scuttle. When you compare it to every other scuttle out there, it's so paper thin and flimsy, it can be broken very easily. Mine feels like one of those china coffee cups, paper thin. I bought really just to check it out. It's jet black, and when it was curing in the kiln, it got some white paint on the lid, He still charged me for it. He did give me the option not to buy it, if you consider that an option.
I wound up getting the dirty bird scuttle 1.5.. Only used it once and had to send it back because the finish wasn't that great.. But the people at dirty bird are top rate and are gonna correct the problem.. I really thought a scuttle would b different I'm getting a warm lather.. But not much better then I was getting using a bowl resting in hot sink water.. By no means is dirty bird a bad scuttle it's top notch.. But for me money I'll stick with my bowl and brush..
I've found that the scuttles that hold 4 cups of water really keep the lather warm/hot.
4 cups of water in the microwave for 3 mins is about right, ymmv.
I had similar heat loss problems with smaller scuttles. I tried sitting them on potholders, and even putting little rubber feet on the bottom, just to reduce surface heat loss. The rubber feet are nice anyway just to keep the scuttle in place.
I am gonna try that foot thing. I hate my new scuttle banging my uneven sink when I whip up a lather. And 3 min in the microwave is too hot to hold except by the handle but the lather is toasty. Just use a lil extra water so it doesn't dry out for the second pass. :idea:
I don't put the scuttle in the microwave, I should have been clear about that. I fill it first with hot tap water, while water is heating up in the microwave. While that's going on, I'm doing a hot towel on my face, then pre shave oil. Once the water is ready (large measuring cup) I pour out the tap water, and refill the scuttle.
Of course, YMMV. Microwaves are different powers, and scuttles hold different amounts.
I have the Roberts scuttle that holds over 4 cups and has a lid...works great...looks like hell...yous gets what yous pay for.
I have an electric tea kettle (the black thing in the corner) on the counter I turn on before getting in the shower. It's boiling by the time I get out and fill my Georgetown Pottery G20 Scuttle about 1/2 to 3/4 with boiling water and the rest with tap. Nice hot brush/lather every time!
Attachment 128233
I have a Dirty Bird 1.5 in Berry Rim on Blue with regular lather ridges. It keeps my lather very warm throughout my longest shaves (upwards of 35 minutes). Julie was a pleasure to work with when I ordered and she finished the item on schedule. The scuttle was delivered very well wrapped with little chance of being broken in the mail unless it were delivered by Ace Ventura. The regular ridges really help provide enough friction to help produce a great lather without trapping the lather in them at all. I've used a 2.0 with web ridges and it's a monster suitable for two people; the web ridges tended to trap lather in them as well. There's a lip on the inside of the top so the lather doesn't creep out as easily.
I'm very happy and feel that the product I received was well worth the money I spent on it. I hope this helps.
K here is what i do while I'm in the shower I fill the scuttle with the hottest tap water and the bowl on top with hot tap water.. Let the brush sit on top in the bowl while I shower.. Out of the shower I dump the water and refill the scuttle with hottest tap water again and start lathering.. U doing anything different?
That's exactly what I do. Missed your comment yesterday afternoon or I wouldn't have written a review of a scuttle you already got.
You got it !,,Quote:
Originally Posted by Airportcopper
I have a DB 1.5 and it is great. I went with the normal ridges and had Julie put in a dribble port Julie is awesome to work with and I would highly recommend doing business with her.
What's a dribble port?
A dribble port is just a small hole drilled near the top. If you need to add water while you are building lather you just tip the scuttle and some of the water dribbles in. It's not necessary but it was available so I figured I would give it a try. You have to email Julie to add it. She will also do different colors with in reason even though its not listed on her site. I wanted just a plain black one and she made it for me. Like I said she is great to work with.
