I'm sure this has been posted here previously, (it's late and frankly, I'm lazy right now,) but I've recently been turned on to Nivea's post shave balms.
I got the "Sensitive Skin" type, only lightly scented, so that I could use whatever after shave I wanted and not mix scents too much, and have to say I'm duly impressed with this product. It instantly relieves any burn, and within a half hour, my face is not greasy, but is soothed and doing very well.
I usually don't post like this about products, but I'm pretty impressed here, and highly recommend this to everyone. What a difference!
A good shave, a splash of Stephens or Col Conk bay rum, and then a liberal application of Nivea. Smelling and feeling good!