As most of my shaving years i never "got" aftershaves except for stinkiness, and therefore never used any; now I'm looking in to it. So funny seeing so many old classics. I'll get some Clubman next trip to the store.
I have been doing cold water, alum, rinse, witch hazel USP.
USP version is the "official" version with 14% alcohol, and i can hardly smell it.
United States Pharmacopeia
and mmmmmmmm Tanker Ray!