Printable View
Several people here seem to really like Noxema as a pre-shave. I searched SRD with no results and Wal Mart has several different items (including razors). Which product is used for a pre-shave. Or, are all the creams possible depending on personal preference, as most things regarding shaving it seems. :)
Jack
Noxzema Classic Clean Moisturizing Cleansing Cream
This is what I have used Original Cleansing Cream | Product | Noxzema I think it's very similar to Prep's product and I'm guessing Proraso too
Cool thing about it is you get a large tub 12oz for about the same price as the tiny tubs of the other products
Both Noxzema's work well for a pre-shave prep. I prefer the moisturizing version because the smell of camphor and eucalyptus isn't as strong. If you're a big fan of the Proraso pre-shave cream, you may prefer the Noxzema Classic Clean version better.
I recently started using Noxema Classic Clean and I think it works a little better than Proraso because it seems to add a wee bit of slickness to my lather. It is also cheaper and easier for me to get. I am going to stick with it.
As I've said in a previous thread it smells totally different to Proraso to me more like a disinfectant (or a toilet cleaner). However it does work as a preshave, I've not used it as a post shave as the smell lingers. As an aside Mrs W has tried it as a facial cleanser and seems to like it as the contents of the tub seem to be reducing daily or maybe it's evaporated!!
Got a jar of this this morning. I don't like to form an opinion after one use but the shave this morning was VERY nice. I actually waited till I got back to shave. For the past couple of days I've shaved in the morning and in the evening both trying different things. My skin had become a bit more tender than normal. Today there wasn't any tenderness at all and the only thing different was the Noxema. I used water a little warmer than room temp. I put the scuttle and water in the microwave for 1 min, 30 sec. When I use the microwave I've normally used 2 min. So at first the Noxema classic moisturizing cream is a winner.Quote:
Originally Posted by feltspanky
When I find a winner (for me) in a pre and/or post shave I"ll be sticking with them forever I think. I have a few products of soap, etc. that I don't prefer but I bought them and have them and I'll probably never use them. I could give them away as gifts. I could even include a note that says "I hate this stuff. I wouldn't let my dog use it so I'll give it to you. Happy "whatever". :)
The Noxzema is the gift that keeps on giving. I'm happy to hear the product worked well for you. Thanks for giving us an update.
When I have soaps that I don't like to shave with they usually become shower soaps.
Noxzema works great as a preshave--I've been using it for years that way, but I also do something that would be totally frowned upon by the esteemed gentlemen on this forum. After applying the base coat of Noxzema cream I will apply over it a generous lather of CANNED (that's right!) Noxzema Regular shave cream in the white can. The scents are identical so that's not a problem. The resulting shave is as good as any brush/soap/cream combo I have ever tried. Always a zero irritation shave be it with a straight, DE or cartridge when travelling.
I love the brush and soap as much as anyone and the tradition behind it--but 75% of the time it's an all Noxzema shave...Try it--you never know!!!!
Marty E.
The Noxzema in a can works well but don't tell my wife. I wouldn't have an excuse to purchase those silver tip badger brushes. :D
The classic Noxema in the blue tub works for me, but I like the Porsano white pre-shave too.
I give mine to my wife. Sometimes that works for me but there have been some accusations of spousal abuse. :)Quote:
Originally Posted by RezDog
OK a week in and I decided to give Noxzema a full trial as a pre shave, for the last 7 days still not keen on the scent but I have to say it works really well for me. Skin feels great and it definitely improves the glide on the blade. I tried with my DE this morning just for a change, great shave and it seems to preserve moisture in the skin.
So in summary, I still prefer the scent of Proraso, but I'm starting to think Noxzema performs better. Think I'll use Noxzema pre-shave and Proraso post shave, best of both worlds.
Nivea post shave for sensitive skin - WallyWorld for five and a half clams. Very nice in cold weather.Quote:
Originally Posted by Anthony1954
Nivea For Men For Sensitive Skin After Shave Extra Soothing Balm 3.3 fl oz - Walmart.com
I bought the Nivea about a week ago and I do like it. It makes my skin feel real good. But the box of Neutrogena post shave lotion sitting right beside it at Wal Mart I like more as a post shave. I've been using the Neutrogena for a few months. I was looking for the Neutrogena and saw the Nivea. I got the Nivea to try it. It is real nice but I think the Neutrogena is better for me. When I was in the Air Force I was in Alaska and several of us had really bad problems with the skin on our hands cracking. We all tried every product available. We were on a 2x4 mile island so there weren't many products. :) Anyway the Neutrogena lotion we had was the ONLY thing that worked at all and it worked so well I've never forgotten the name. In my mind Neutrogena products are exceptional. From the limited number of products I've tried for shaving it's good for that also.Quote:
Originally Posted by MisterMoo
Jack
After reading this thread, I purchased a huge $4 tub of Noxzema Classic Clean Moisturizing Cleansing Cream. I used it as a pre-shave for the first time yesterday on a 7-day growth beard. Loved it. Best thing I've done to improve my shave. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
sorry for a stupid question but I am easily confused today....
You are using the Noxzema as pre-shave cream and rub/massage into the skin. Then you apply your shave cream over the Noxzema (like you would for any other pre-shave). After applying the shave cream, over the Noxzema that has been massaged into your face, you then shave your face like normal???
I know this sounds stupid and OCD but I am having a moment. Sorry.
Thanks for everyone's patience!
@Tom475
Some Noxema users leave the cream on the face and lather over the cream.
I rinse the Noxema off with water and then lather and shave normally.
So, you can do what works best for you.
I rinse before lathering because I did not like getting the Noxema off the blade. It is a bit sticky.
Give it a try and please give us a full report. It only takes a small amount massaged into your wet whiskers. A little Noxzema goes a long way. If it sticks to your blade during the rinse, your applying it to heavily.Quote:
Originally Posted by tom475
Sometimes it seems like I can use all the same stuff. Same pre-shave, soap,etc. and even with the same products (and razor) I get different shaves and my face feels different when I'm done. I'm one year new to straight shaving so I can't determine what makes the difference. :shrug:
Having said that, I like to rinse off the Noxema or rub it in real well because if I leave it on the surface of my skin it seems to gum up on the razor edge. This seems to make it feel like the razor isn't cutting. Then I rinse the blade under hot running water and I have to wipe some of the gunk off the very edge. When that is happening I normally add water to the brush and either mface lather or with the extra water whip some thinner lather. The goal is to dilute any remaining Noxema on my face. So when using Noxema I don't like any left on the surface of my shin when I shave. Did that make sense? Anyway, it's probably different ways to use the same products that result in different results when I shave.
Jack
Thanks to all for the answers. It is starting to make some sense. Finally sinking through all the layers of granite and all. I may try it as a shower preshave that way I can rinse it all off properly before shaving. I typically shave right after shower any way. Look forward to trying it.
I have a shower dry myself off then rub a small amount of Noxzema into my face fill the sink soak the brush. Hot towel over face, lather face, another hot towel. Lather again then shave. I usually do 3 passes just relathering. Hope that helps.Quote:
Originally Posted by tom475
Noxema Moisturizing is excellent:
- Easy to find
- Affordable
- Works exceptionally well
+1Quote:
Originally Posted by IndependenceRazor1
It certainly helped fight dry skin this winter. I plan to keep on using Noxema into the summer months.
I just recently started using Noxzema as a face cleaner/preshave cleaner a little over 6 weeks ago. I have been using even on days I don't shave. I have noticed that my face is feeling better overall. When I have to stand outside with the icy winds that bite into your bones, my face has not dried out as bad as years past. First time in over 10 years my face has not hurt as bad and the only real "product" change was adding Noxzema to my normal morning shower.
Other people may have different results. I can only share my results and observations.
Shaving does seem to be improved too, after using it for this length of time.
I've been using the Noxema Classic Clean cleanser as a pre-shave since about the beginning of this thread. I think it probably helps when I shave without showering first because I haven't washed my face when showering. I also have some Neutrogena pre-shave cleanser but I don't care for it as a pre-shave because it has scrubbing granuals in it. I'm worried if I don't rinse completely they might degrade the razor's edge. Now if I use Castle Forbes pre-shave after the Noxema that really makes for a noticably smoother shave. But if I don't use both I prefer the Noxema, rinse, shave. I don't know anything for sure but it seems a cleaner face makes more of a difference than the Castle Forbes on a non-cleaned face.
SO
Clean with Noxema then shave with Mitchell's wool fat soap is a very nice shave. Add the Castle Forbes pre-shave and it's REALLY nice. Noxema will remain part of the every shave routine. Castle Forbes is when I've been good and deserve a reward. :)
Jack
I tried the classic one, but I didn't see any difference. It does not work for everyone, I guess.
If you have a Kroger store near you they have a Blue Jar generic Noxzema that is exactly the same but about 3/4 the price. I have been using it for years and use it every time for cleaning the face before shaving. bj
I can feel the difference in my heard after a couple minutes covered with Noxema Classic Clean. Before- normal, brillstley, sharp.
After- rubbery, not sharp and almost soft plastic like. (I guess that would be rubbery)
I never believed I'd find a product replacement for my beloved Noxzema Cleansing Cream. It's still the best value around for the price. I must report my shaves are more enjoyable with this Neutrogena product.
Recently I saw this product on my local grocery store shelf for 3.99. First, I experimented using the product without any other traditional shaving soaps or creams. It works well but the shaver loses the enjoyment of the traditional wet shaving experience. Upon further experimentation, I began substituting the Neutrogena in place of my Noxzema Cleansing Cream. I rub just a small amount of Neutrogena into my wet whiskers. I use my brush and lather my favorite scented soap or cream directly over-top the Neutrogena. I complete my WTG pass, rinse with cold water and repeat the process before each razor pass.
I experienced my best S.R. shave to date. The shave was on par with a DE razor, Muhle R41 and feather blade Zen experience. The Neutrogena doesn't have a strong scent like Noxzema Cleansing Cream. It doesn't mask the scent of your favorite shaving soap or cream. For those shavers who are turned off by the smell of Noxzema this is a wonderful alternative. I'll be replacing Noxzema with Neutrogena in my shaving routine.
http://www.neutrogena.com/product/ne...shave+cream.do
I just finished my jar of Noxema Classic. Seven months for $4.69 USD is a really inexpensive product that gives great results.
My new Noxema is the Classic with Moisturizer. It is creamier and I like it. After a week of use I cannot really say my skin is benefitting from the moisturizer component but it is the same price as the Classic.
I am going to keep using the Noxema. My face did survive the winter with far less irritation.
Agreed, the Noxzema Cleansing Cream is the best deal around for a pre-shave lubricant and facial moisturizer. My only complaint was the smell. It over powered the fragrance of my shaving soaps and creams. I've been using the Neutrogenia in my preshave routine and very happy with the results.
My Mom always used Noxema so I guess the smell brings back childhood memories.Quote:
Originally Posted by feltspanky
If I can find that Neutrogena I will give it a go.