ABC vs SMN Pre-Shave

[Steve56]

Gentlemen,

If you read the forum posts here and yon, you’ll find that opinions about the value of pre-shave products range from rubbish to essential. I’ve been testing the ABC Almond Oil and Aloe Pre-Shave Cream and the Santa Maria Novella ‘Before and After Shave Cream’.

My opinion is and has always been, that these products do very little for hair, they’re primarily skin conditioners. If you don’t have a skin condition that they are effective at improving, there’s little reason to use them. They might increase soap slickness marginally, but if your soap isn’t slick enough you need to be using better soap not a pre-shave product. That said, I have an area of ruddy dry skin on my upper face, around the lower forehead and upper cheeks, and both these products are quite effective at diminishing that condition, so I am a fan.

What are they though, cosmetically? Both are ‘active ingredients’, like almond oil, aloe, and other familiar oils and butters in a vegetable triglyceride base. Both also contain a couple of other moisturizing ingredients frequently found in other cosmetics and face creams.

How do they compare? The SMN product is interesting because you can use it as a pre-shave product, a shaving cream, and a post shave balm. I’ve tried it in all three modes and it does not excel as a shaving cream compared to traditional offerings but it will work especially if you wet it down a good bit. But stick to the 3Ts for shaving cream. As a pre-shave or after shave balm, it works well. It’s a heavier product then ABC and takes longer to rinse it off if that’s what you desire. The scent is a powdery pomegranate scent that would pair well with Mitchell’s Wool Fat shaving soap.

The ABC product is lighter product, rinses easily, and is almost scentless. It is described only as a pre-shave product. I did the above ingredient research because SMN says that it can be used post shave, so how about ABC which is cosmetically quite similar? Why yes it can! I’ve tried it and it is an excellent balm, especially if you like lighter ones. It is not greasy and absorbs quickly, and leaves an excellent skin feel. The lack of a noticeable scent is a plus for ABC as an AS balm if you‘re following it with fragrance.

Neither of these products are cheap, ABC is about $47 US and SMN even more, about $58 US. Both are 100ml. They are ‘rich’ products and you would typically only use about 1/4 ml per day, so that’s about a year‘s worth. If you have dry or ruddy skin, they might well be worth it, and traveling with a bit of ABC means that you likely don’t need AS. If you have a normal non-fussy complexion or oily skin, they probably aren’t going to do much for you.