Good thread! I've been using MWF almost exclusively for the last 4 years or so. My only complaint is that it dries out too quickly, but I'm a slow shaver in a dry climate so that might be the reason. I can get a great lather on my face, in a scuttle, and even in the bowl it comes with - it just takes a little pre-soak and a bit of time working the puck with the bristle ends... OK a LOT of time developing the lather. But once it comes in it has to be the best lather I've experienced.
My wife loves the scent of MWF so that may influence me some. I found the bath soap they sell and bought some bars for her (she started using my MWF for her legs). I'm wondering if anyone else has tried the bath soap and if they also think it doesn't really smell like the shaving soap. I can't smell any similarity at all - but the lanolin is certainly in the bathing soap as well.